A photo of Whitney Williams, who was only 2-years-old when she died after being physically abused.
PRINCESS ANNE, Md. (AP)– The Somerset County Department of Social Services on Monday settled a suit brought by the father of a fatally abused child for $50,000.
The father, Clark Bell, sued Somerset County Social Services for $1 million, claiming the agency ignored reports that his daughter, 2-year-old Whitney Williams, was being abused at her mother’s home.
Whitney died in October 2002. Her mother, Carole Anne Quillen, was convicted of manslaughter and was sentenced to a five-year prison term. Quillen’s boyfriend, Christopher Allen, was sentenced to 25 years in prison for child abuse resulting in death.
Bell will receive $48,000. Another $2,000 was granted to the Williams estate, which in effect grants $1,000 each to Bell and Quillen. (Source: Somerset County, MD)
A lawsuit has been filed and is seeking class action status against the department alleging violations of constitutional rights. Nine Latina child care workers claim the state came into their homes and seized personal records in search of ‘phantom children’. The lawsuit also alleges discrimination against child care workers on the basis of ethnicity and language.
Register your Department of Social and Health Services Case
If you feel you qualify for damages or remedies that might be awarded in a possible class action or lawsuit, please click the link below to submit your complaint. By submitting this form, you are asking lawyers to contact you. You are under no obligation to accept their services. Lawyers are usually paid out of the proceeds of the settlement or verdict rendered.
Please click here for a free evaluation of your case
Columbia Legal Services – Joe Morrison
Columbia Legal Services – Joe Morrison
“Its ALmost Tuesday” and its blogowner is merely providing you with a link to register your Department of Social and Health Services case; we make no promises, form no opinions as to how your case may be evaluated; and we are not lawyers nor giving legal advice.
Yakima County, WA
Yakima County, WA: (May-26-07) Tim Farris, a Bellingham, WA lawyer and critic of Washington’s foster-care system, has been known to repeatedly file lawsuits against the State Department of Social and Health Services. He filed one more lawsuit against the department recently, on behalf of injured children, accusing the department and social workers of negligence over the sexual abuse of an 8-year-old foster child. Farris said the abuse occurred in the summer of 2002, shortly after the 8-year-old was placed in the home of a new foster mother in Ellensburg. Also in the home was an older boy that Farris said had a documented history of sexually aggressive behavior. He said DSHS failed to properly train the foster mother and did not even warn her that the older boy had such problems. In a related twist, a social worker assigned to investigate the abuse allegations was fired by a supervisor who was the husband of the supervisor of the social worker who made the placement. As part of the settlement that Farris reached with the county, the sexual abuse lawsuit was resolved with a $290,000 payout. [YAKIMA HERALD: FOSTER ABUSE]
Washington, DC: The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission reports that Mattel has received more than 400 reports of magnets coming loose in products such as Polly Pocket, Doggie Day Care, Barbie & Tanner, Batman and “Sarge” Die Cast toy cars.
Unfortunately, under the Bush administration, the US Consumer Product Safety Commission staff has been cut more than 10 percent in recent years. This leaves fewer regulators available to monitor the growing flood of imported toys from China.
9 million toys recalled
There have been several reports of serious injuries to children who swallowed magnets from the toys. According to the Commission, “all three suffered intestinal perforations that required surgery.”
As a result, Mattel has issued a recall affecting more than 9 million toys, citing magnets that could be swallowed and possible problems with lead paint.
Its Fisher-Price division recalled 1.5 million preschool toys from a different supplier earlier this month.
Safety agency under-funded
The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission “doesn’t have the staff that they need to try to get ahead of this problem,” according to Janell Mayo Duncan, senior counsel at the Consumers Union, which publishes Consumer Reports. “They need more money and resources to do more checks.”
The Commission is a government agency designed to “protect the public from risks of serious injury or death from more than 15,000 types of consumer products under [its] jurisdiction”, including appliances and children’s toys. It was created in 1972 by Congress under the Consumer Product Safety Act, to protect the public “against unreasonable risks of injuries associated with consumer products.”
Unfortunately, the current presidential administration has been whittling away at the Commission’s funding, leaving it with scarce resources to monitor the millions of imports entering the US market.
Made in China
More than 80 percent of toys on U.S. store shelves are manufactured in China. Last year, China exported $7 billion worth of toys to more than 160 countries.
Representatives in China have defended the industry’s safety record there. “Although there are a few problems with some made-in-China toys, generally the safety quality is worthy of being trusted,” the official Xinhua news agency stated in a recent release, citing unnamed officials from two industry associations.
Critics are unconvinced, however, charging that American companies have shipped their manufacturing operations to China in order to cut costs, at the expense of safety standards.
Julie Vallese, a Consumer Product Safety Commission spokeswoman said “Is there a concern that there are more products coming in from China and making sure they live up to the standards we expect? Yes, there is.”
The New York Times reports that “China was source of all toys recalled this year.”
Recall lists online
Concerned parents can find comprehensive recall information online at the US Consumer Product Safety Commission [CPSC].
Product recall and warning information is also available at [PARENTS MAGAZINE].
Advocate: US companies “should be held liable”
Across the country, lawsuits are being filed on behalf of parents against Mattel and other toy companies, to compensate families and to ensure that companies take steps to prevent more accidents.
“These are items that children are supposed to be playing with,” said Prescott Carlson, co-founder of a Web site called the Imperfect Parent, which includes a section that tracks recalls of toys and other baby products.
“It should be at a point where companies in the United States that are importing these items are held liable.”